Findings & Footnotes February 2017

  • The way that church music assumes a central place in how Christians identify with their churches is nowhere more evident than in charismatic and Pentecostal Christianity—a fact borne out in the fascinating new book The Spirit of Praise (Penn State University Press, $32.95), edited by Monique M. Ingalls and Amos Yong. “Praise and worship” music has become far more than the beginning part of a worship service for Pentecostals; today this type of contemporary Christian music is represented by brands and movements spanning the globe and adapted by a wide range of believers. The contributors document the diversity of styles and uses of this music, including a chapter on Australia’s aboriginal Christian music, which forms a bridge between indigenous traditions (surrounding the myth of songlines) and the white Pentecostal traditions.

    Another chapter on Australia looks at how its popular Hillsong music coming from a megachurch movement by that name is standardized and thus strongly unifying as it has circulated throughout the world from its Australian base. Other contributions look at how the CCM repertoire has made its way into the Gospel music tradition of black churches, bringing it into contact with churches of other ethnicities, and the growth of neo-Pentecostal churches and music among the Navajo Nation in the American Southwest, with its music’s effectiveness due to its similarity with the repetitive and “soaking” quality of native chants and songs. In the conclusion, Amos Yong argues that both homogenization and diversity take place through the globalized circulation of praise and worship music, adding that this two-way pattern may increasingly be evident in the theological reflection and teachings that accompany it in world Pentecostalism.

  • Alevis in Europe (Routledge, $136), edited by Tozun Issa, looks at a movement in Turkey and Europe that often gets lost in the glare of attention on orthodox Islam. The origins of the Alevis and whether they are strictly a religion, a way of life, or an ethnicity are disputed. Most followers claim they are a distinct faith from Islam, since they do not practice the five pillars of Islam, nor do they go to a mosque, though they venerate Ali, the cousin of Muhammad, and other Muslim “saints.” Alevism has changed from a strongly communal orientation to a more secularized and urban Turkish identity in the Twentieth Century. The contributors note that the core of the diverse movement has shifted from embracing a more leftist ideology to a “religious reorientation” in recent years, partly as a response to the Islamic revival. The Alevi emigration to Europe, covered in the second half of the book, has brought more changes to the movement, not least the loss of the “dede,” the communal sacred leader, and the establishment of cemevi, places of worship replacing home-based worship.Alevis growth and concentration in Germany has hastened their religious revival, often as a way to differentiate themselves from Turkish Muslim immigrants. The movement has gained wide acceptance, with Germany recognizing Alevis as a model community. A study on Alevis in England (largely from Kurdish backgrounds) finds that they have their strongest differences with Sunni Muslims, with the former stressing gender equality and progressive political views. Another chapter looks at how Alevis have become a transnational community, forming organizations and media that span the Turkish-European borders, and pressing both their European countries and Turkey to recognize them as a legitimate faith community.